Your Guide to Reinventing Michigan
by Nettie Boivin
March 3rd, 2008 in Advice, Art, Careers, Creative, Energy, Events, Green, Lifestyle, Newsletter, Talent, The Reinvention Issue
Sorting through the news around the state, a rising tide is pushing Michigan closer to reinvention. From young professionals and arts organizations to corporations and nonprofits, thousands are taking Michigan’s success personally. The final nudge toward the tipping point — you.
Here’s a primer on where we stand and how you can help.

Flickr ID: Kaddy
Michigan’s Future: The Current Situation
You may remember the MiLife MiTimes report on the Myth of the Brain Drain. Certainly, Michigan wants to attract and retain as many talented, upwardly mobile people as possible.
Here’s the key. Those people want five things: the arts, research universities, mass transit, downtown and near-downtown neighborhoods, and green or outdoor spaces.
Each of these desires is highlighted by Lou Glazer, president of Michigan Future and one of the state’s most valuable urban planners. In a recent Free Press interview, he urged that “[Michigan] needs a new agenda. We’re not working on the talent part of it.”
Glazer’s recent study, “Michigan’s Transition to a Knowledge-Based Economy: First Annual Report” revealed that Michigan dropped from 16th to 26th nationally in per-capita income earnings — a telling plunge of 10 spots while remaining 34th in percentage of Americans with a four-year degree or higher.
Translation: High-paying jobs for uneducated workers are disappearing and the playing field is correcting itself.
However, as in the perpetuation of the brain drain myth, many headlines overlooked part of the report.
Between 2001 and 2005, Michigan added about 47,000 higher-paying jobs in the health care and higher education industries. About 30,000 of those were in metro Detroit with much of the remainder near Grand Rapids.
It’s not all doom and gloom.
This video of Glazer offers a great download on Michigan’s potential.
He points out that Google, the “coolest company in the world,” chose to move its AdWords HQ to Ann Arbor for a reason — talent. Feels good to have a company that’s practically closing in on world domination attracting and employing so many bright minds right here in Michigan.
The Knowledge Economy - Rise of the Left Brainers
To build a knowledge economy, we need to educate and retain those brains. So it seems logical that the State should put a huge spending priority on higher education, right?
Here’s some disturbing news. The Pew Center just reported that Michigan is one of only four states that spends more on prisons than higher education. More of our thinly-stretched budget ($2 billion dollars worth) is spent on keeping people behind bars than upholding the excellence of our 15 public universities. (Ugh.) To her credit, Gov. Granholm did address this unfortunate disparity in this year’s budget as she proposed trimming $50 million from the prisons and asked state leaders to take a closer look at Corrections reform.
Meanwhile, the University Research Corridor — comprised of MSU, WSU and U-M — is taking the state’s economic future into its own hands by investing a combined $1 billion a year to attract businesses in rapidly growing industries such as life sciences, alternative energy, advanced manufacturing and information technology, creating nearly 70,000 jobs in 2006 alone.
While the State tries to figure out how to spend more on our universities and less on prisons, other groups are at work to keep the well-educated through internships and creative careers.
One such group is MORE (Michigan Opportunities and Resources for Entrepreneurs). Executive Director and Detroit-native Jessica Pfeiffer has a lot to say on the topic of retaining college graduates. She’s creating connections between Michigan’s talent and the state’s most innovative companies, as seen in the upcoming Entrepreneurial Opportunities Day on March 19 at the University of Michigan.
Then there’s the responsible, philanthropic foundations like the 10 community organizations who’ve together pooled $100 million in eligible grants called the New Economy Initiative (NEI). Nonprofits and government agencies can apply for up to $1 million through 2015 or as long as funds are available.
“This is the single biggest pooled investment that a consortium of foundations has ever made in urban America,” said Rip Rapson, president of the Troy-based Kresge Foundation, in an interview with Model D Media.
Share your thoughts on how to move the region forward and learn about the NEI grant process here.
The Creative Economy - Rise of the Right Brainers
Imagine it. Silicon Valley in California. Research Triangle in North Carolina. Next up: Creative Corridor in Michigan.
Detroit Renaissance, an organization of Detroit’s top-brass business leaders, is putting mega bucks into the development of a few miles of Woodward Ave. with plans to market it nationally as the Creative Corridor. The $80 million “Road to Renaissance” project aims to attract the best, brightest and most creative companies to a strip that already includes Wayne State University, Detroit Institute of Art (DIA), Museum of Contemporary Art Detroit (MOCAD), and the College of Creative Studies (CCS).
“For younger professionals especially, it’s important they know they don’t have to go to Chicago or New York. There’s a tradition of creativity right here,” said Mary Kramer, the Crain’s publisher awarded the project to create an asset map of creative companies.
Then there’s ArtServe Michigan, the statewide organization that advocates for artists, cultural institutions and K-12 educators. Under new president Neeta Delaney, the nonprofit works to offer resources, connections and funding to Michigan’s vital arts and culture community.
Approaching their annual Arts & Culture Advocacy Day in Lansing on March 19, Delaney envisions a marriage of arts and culture supporters and environmentalists to conceive a stronger sector with a united voice. The goal is to ensure that the state’s natural and cultural resources maintain priority seating in Michigan’s agenda for a competitive edge in the new economy.
Also in the mix, there’s the combined star-power of Mitch Albom, Jeff Daniels and Mike Binder who took their filmmaking experience to Lansing and set forth a plan to import millions of dollars from Hollywood to Michigan.
Albom and Binder presented to a Senate Committee on January 22, leading to a fast-tracked proposed incentive package that would give filmmakers a 40% tax break. Up from today’s 20%, this would make Michigan the most attractive location to shoot TV and film productions.
Senate hearings on the package begin on March 4. See several related articles from MiLifeMiTimes.com here.
Finally, anyone who cares about the success of our cities should look forward to the Creative Cities Summit 2.0 in October at the Renaissance Center.
“We are thrilled to bring this event to Michigan, in particular to Detroit, where these ideas are already underway,” said Peter Kageyama of Creative Cities Productions, the producers of the event. “We saw this as an opportunity to use the metaphor of Detroit as the epitome of the American industrial city that is creatively remaking itself in the 21st century.”
Topics will include place making, talent attraction, retention strategies and best practices for economic and social development. Planners also are developing a unique event specifically for the young and talented to share their voice and vision for Michigan’s cities of the future.
What Can You Do?
Take the day off and join the movement for a creative economy at ArtServe’s Arts & Culture Advocacy Day on March 19.
Join the Creative Cities Summit 2.0 Facebook Group to get updates on the event.
Support the Film Incentive Package by getting involved with Creative Energy Alliance and the Michigan Production Alliance.
Include your company on the Creative Corridor’s Asset Map.
Comments
Nettie Boivin writes:
March 6th, 2008 at 9:31 pm
Jocelyne - We appreciate you taking the time to read and respond. It’s a shame that your experience here was such that it drove you away. I found it interesting that you were moving to New Orleans just as I was moving in from Chicago. Interesting because my experience here has been quite the opposite of yours.
Your comments reflect the caustic remarks I was practically bludgeoned with from the moment I moved in. It took me nearly two years to shake the resulting bad attitude and dig out from that ugly impression. While many of your points can’t be denied and definitely should not be ignored, it is my intent – and that of this site - to highlight the people, places and things that are moving Michigan forward. This site and I may be “new” - but how do you suggest we advance the situation if we stick with the “old.” I think we both agree that the old way of thinking is exactly how Michigan got stuck in such a mess to begin with.
Also, I’m curious, can you tell us how you tried to affect change while you were here? I ask, because I am truly trying to identify and promote ways a new generation of talent can impact change instead of becoming jaded, complacent and apathetic. I want to understand what great efforts have been made and why they failed.
I believe life is made up of a series of decisions that get you to where you stand today. Some things are totally out of my control But I chose to move here. I choose to stay here. And I choose to insert myself and all my capacities into the movement toward a progressive Michigan. MiLifeMiTimes chooses to spotlight like-minded people and organizations. We don’t mean to sugar-coat - but we absolutely mean to look at life here from new perspectives.
Add Your Response
Enter AIGA's Celebrate Michigan Poster Design Contest.
The Career SociaList
by Nettie Boivin
Looking for a job? This is one area where social networking shines in making life a lot easier. Here are 10 sites that will help in the "It's all about who you know" department.
The Creative SociaList
by Nettie Boivin
From DIYers to graphic designers, these sites bring you unprecedented access to artists, photographers, designers and their work in Michigan and around the globe.
The Music SociaList
by Scotter Bragg
Radio has given way to iTunes and MySpace - and bands and fans benefit with more music offerings than ever before.
The Green SociaList
by Scotter Bragg
Green is a movement. Green is a new way of living. And green is all over the internet. Here are our favorite sites that connect you to eco-friendly friends and resources.
The Entertainment SociaList
by Bradley Gula
If an exciting night means paper football and a Designing Women marathon, social media is here to help.
- Sonic Drive-In to Debut in Grand Rapids, Michigan
- Michigan Snowfall Tops Average This Season
- Rothbury Music Festival to Launch at Lake Michigan Double JJ Resort
- Downriver Sonic Opening Soon in Southgate, Michigan
- New York Times on Detroit's Revival
- The 10 List - Coolest Gifts Made in Michigan
- Michigan Is for Gay Lovers
- Miss Michigan Gina Valo Reigns at Google
- Southeast Michigan Cities Approaching Seasonal Snowfall Records
- What Everyone Must Know About the Brain Drain Myth in Michigan
- Yee-haw!: in March, MiLifeMiTimes’ Nikki Stephan wrote candidly about the event — dubbed...
- jpfeffer: Thanks for the comment and information, David. It is definitely worth weighing all of your...
- Benny: When is this place gonna open already!!?!?!??!?!?!
- Heather Carmona: This is a great list! Thanks for sharing. I participated in the Green Street Fair...
- Lena Thompson: The 28% fewer mpg is based on BTU formula alone and nothing else. There are many...












Jocelyne Ninneman writes:
March 4th, 2008 at 10:30 pm
I have been getting this newsletter for a while now. I have shaken my head with each read. But it was not until now, that I finally took some time out of my jam-packed day to actually respond to this issue.
First of all, to even post articles even mildly suggesting that the brain-drain in MI is a myth, is sheer ignorance. No, it may not be to the extent that some may advocate, but maybe that sort “state of urgency” is what is needed for people to actually care.
It seems there are alot of “authorities” on this topic. Yet, I wonder how many of them have actually experienced the drastic decline of the Detroit region, and Michigan as a whole, over the past 5 years.
How many “experts” watched all their friends and colleagues leave for greener pastures in “real” cities, how many were crushed by unfinished projects into which went months or years of heart & soul?
Sure, that may be an increase in “higher education” jobs in the “information / knowledge” field, thanks to the universities, but how many THOUSANDS of people have lost their jobs and homes in Michigan in the past 5 years?
70,000 new jobs do not replace the HUNDREDS of thousands of people that lost their jobs, and often homes, due in large part to 3 major auto corporations for which there is no accountability.
Compound that with a city and state bureaucracy that is beyond ridiculous, and good luck opening a new business.
What gets me the most is this: You advocate for young entrepreneurs to create and open their own businesses.
Great.
How long will that take? 3 years? 5 years?
Then, once the strong (or rich) few do open, WHO are their customers going to be???
People with their homes in foreclosure?
People that just lost a job they’ve had for 20 years?
People that suffer from some of the worst primary education systems in the country?
Yes, Governor Granholm does get it, and she tried. But instead, she will be blamed for the state’s demise… a demise which was in motion long before she came into office.
People such as myself do not appreciate publications and organizations that are too new to be deeply rooted in actual communities sugar-coating the situation and promoting false-advertising for Michigan.
Yes, Michigan is a great place. It has great forests and lakes and farms… it has some cities with great potential. It has some of the world’s most remarkable architecture. And MOST OF ALL: it has the highest concentration of truly innovative talent.
Yet, these YOUNG people have NO support networks. They are receiving some of the worst primary educations.
Yes, financial support of higher education is crucial… but let’s remember that to even GET to that level, PRIMARY education and community-building will be the determining factors of who even gets to those higher education opportunities.
Yes, I do agree that the disgusting amount of money spent on incarcerating people is unforgivable considering the education crisis. Hm, perhaps if people had the skills and knowledge to solve problems, there would not be such a need for so many prisons…
The bottom line is that: Michigan is always late to the party, so to speak. To be jumping on the “information age” train now is already late. And one of the main reasons we are always last to the party is because those in positions of power are both afraid of change, afraid of merging, and most of all, want the next phase to look solely as they perceive it.
If the “Big 3″ and all related transportation & energy companies in Michigan we smart, they would reserve what open farmland is left in MI to grown vegetable fuel, subsidize the farmland, and put organic-fuel-powered vehicles on the market like no other company. Then MI could lead that economy, and the MI auto industry could begin to redeem itself. And of course, this is only ONE way big moves could be made in MI.
This does include the entire issue of Detroit, and Michigan, refusing to capitalize on the economy of CULTURE. Flat-out refusing. Even the “Visitors Bureau” denies proposals for guided music tours of the city.
As a native Detroiter, who spent many summers, and even falls, in northern Michigan, I must say that there is some serious re-thinking that needs to happen at the core, and the heart, of the people before we can even hope to move forward.
I have lived in New Orleans for the past 3 years now - a city RAVAGED by 2 hurricanes and a flood in 1 month’s time. And do you know that the people of New Orleans have ALOT to teach the people of Detroit (MI) about supporting their OWN first, about capitalizing on their inherent hometown culture, and about just how powerful this resource can be in re-building a fallen metropolis…?
Michigan refused to diversify its economy for too long, and if the primary educational systems necessary to do just that are not put in place immediately, MI may miss this bus too…
I had to leave Michigan as a new grad because I went through [4] jobs in one year. All of them were lay-offs or businesses going out of business, except for one: one I was fired from because I was late too many times because I relied on the Detroit bus system to get to work, and it failed to be reliable.
How are you going to sugar-coat that one?